|
Thursday, May 23rd, 2013 |
|
Home
RSS Feed
Newsletter
Boomark Us
Facebook
Twitter
|
|
Libertarian Visions of Schooling in the Future and Reform
Paul Hakel
This morning I was reading that Ben Swann, host of Reality Check, was homeschooled and earned his master’s degree by the age of 17 through BYU (http://cincinnati.com/blogs/tv/2010/12/13/meet-ben-swann-new-fox19-anchor/). As I’ve written before, I think this is the future of education: I was calling for the achievement of bachelor-level degrees by the time people finish high school, but maybe it’s time to start dreaming for Ph.D. levels to be achieved? If this is what one homeschooling family is achieving, what kind of schools could we have if we had properly trained teachers and the freedom for individual students to develop themselves without friction? Clearly, the level of education at our schools must not be very high if homeschoolers like Ben Swann are successful – he is not merely an isolated case. You’d think that with all the educating we do in the U.S. that we’d have some super-geniuses emerging – plenty of Mozarts and Einsteins. Unfortunately, though, with a $15 Trillion Dollar U.S. Federal Gov’t and whole hosts of problems, the achievements of the public (and private) school system seem to be lacking. The question we should ask ourselves is, “How can I personally make U.S. schooling better?” Is it through attending more Parent-Teacher Conferences and through parents getting more of a direct involvement in the schools as some parents have been literally taking over school districts? Perhaps we need to think more on a philosophy and practicality of education in our modern world. The hallmark of good education is inculcating a passionate love of learning which is free to inquire and follow thoughts where they lead, as well as providing the tools and role models for answering questions and showing a student how to do things and achieve excellence. I remember seeing Ayn Rand speak about how she dealt with Soviet Russia’s poor education system. When she was in grade school, she said she would put up a couple folders to block the teacher’s view and would write novels behind them! The intelligent mind will always find ways to endure and hopefully triumph over damaging forces around them, yet the more we can do to help that mind soar, the more developed of a world we can create. “The Closing of the American Mind” by Allan Bloom was a conservative lament for education I read some time ago. While I don’t agree with everything Mr. Bellow said, I do agree that our higher education institutions have “impoverished the souls of today’s students”. Far too much now we have a “political correctness” in schools that goes out of it’s way to read inferior quality work in order to be inclusive of other cultures, rather than support and defend the “Western White European Christian Dead Old Men’s” writing, which is generally what constitutes a lot of what are often universally agreed to be the “classics” of thought. The inequality of cultures and of ideas is certainly not a popular idea today, yet is directly contradicted by the fact that we think some ideas are “better” than others. Are we aiming to be geniuses today above the fools or is everyone of the radical egalitarian breed that “everyone is smart”? Without being snobbish or racist, we should be objective and allow to speak freely and without arbitrary discrimination. We have to remember that many who are considered “classic” today may have been vehemently hated in their day, and we need to have the freedom to love (and hate) again today as well. Alfie Kohn, while very socialist in his thought, does bring up important considerations for our incessant focus on standardization and competition in his book, “No Contest” as well as other essays. Is the SAT really an accurate measure of intelligence and skills? Tests such as the SAT, barring any claims of cultural bias, do give some kind of accurate assessment of one’s logic and verbal skills. Yet, does it measure how well you can play [or use] a musical (or surgical) instrument? Does it measure your emotional intelligence (E.Q.)? Where is the dissent about the limitations of the SAT to measure intelligence? Maybe this is another conspiracy I have yet to research, about how the College Board (makers of the SAT) gained such prominence and influence in the higher education system… Another book I recall reading but don’t remember too much about is “Anti-Intellectualism in American Life” by Richard Hofstadter. I personally LOVE to read books more than I love breathing air and don’t know how anyone can live without the things (or the internet)! How many people do you know who call themselves an “intellectual” today? In a non-discriminating, socialized education system, no longer are there the “smart” and the “stupid”. Has being an intellectual become physicalized, become a neuroscience and business, of sorts? What happened to purely intellectual pursuits? What happened to high achievement by the intellect? Has it become too costly, too unfashionable, or are we just too lazy to read? Another book I remember reading, when trying to figure out this education puzzle while I was stuck in its prison halls was “The Case Against Homework” by Sara Bennett and Nancy Kalish. This book was excellent about how students should have the freedom to do work at school and to relax at home. Do you go to your job and then bring home work to do? Some people do voluntarily – how about we have students do so voluntarily if they want to get ahead? Regardless: do we really need to make our youth take work home to do? I’m not against the idea, but do think that some students might learn better by having school year round with less hours and by doing more work during school hours rather than school hours AND hours at home. When I look back at my youth, I probably could have benefitted from some kind of arrangement like that – I just remember there being one way of doing things and that was it. I recall reading that the structure of school from Fall to Spring was created to accommodate agricultural society. Well, we’re not exactly that kind of society anymore, so could we find more efficient ways to do things and give kids more freedom? One book I especially liked was “The Teenage Liberation Handbook” by Grace Llewellyn – but unfortunately I was in college when I was first reading it. This book was about “unschooling” or about autodidactism or self-taught learning. It gave a bunch of book ideas and internship-esque or employment opportunities for young people to look for rather than “traditional” schooling (I don’t like to use the term “traditional” because I believe in “traditional” models, to some extent, but think they have become grossly perverted). Unschooling seemed appealing to me because I taught myself how to do a lot of things that I loved doing and also found refuge in my own research skills rather than working with some incompetent or uncaring teachers. Yet, as every unschooler would have to agree, unschooling is NOT exactly being “self-taught”. It’s more like customized-choice-of-teachers-through-books. Books are the ability for a teacher to teach at a distance; reading a book is like learning from a teacher, only in a visual way. One thread I gather from all of these readings: legislation like the “No Child Left Behind” Act is extremely short-sighted about the diversity of approaches required for ensuring educational excellence. Can education thrive without moral foundation? How can we use technology to further educational goals (or when should we abstain from using it, like in teaching young people how to garden and grow their own food)? What is a libertarian education system? What does it mean to be “well educated”? How can we work to get the cost of education down? (In other countries, there are riots about the cost of education – perhaps we need more protest and demand for cheap education in the U.S. in order to get it?) What’s the endgame of our education, what do we really want to use it to do? All comments and thoughts below are appreciated! This article has been generously contributed by Paul Hakel Delivered by The Daily Sheeple Contributed by Paul Hakel of www.TheDailySheeple.com. Please share: Spread the word to sheeple far and wide
Leave A Comment... |
Break away from the herd and stay up to date with The Daily Sheeple.
           |
v.8
The Closing of the American Mind was written by Allan Bloom, not Saul Bellow. These kinds of mistakes cause one to question the integrity of what you write.
You might enjoy John Taylor Gatto’s books.
Carloyn – Thanks, the introduction was written by Saul Bellow on my version and you’re correct, Allan Bloom is the author – if the webmaster might amend that.
HansLoco – have read John Taylor Gatto, he has excellent stuff. Should have included him, but he didn’t immediately come to mind in reaction to the Ben Swann article.
Got that updated for you Paul.
Lets see, how to educate the young? Most employers want peoplewho come up with neew ideas and can work in collaborative groups. Math is emphaized but lrittle is used after graduation and in the work force.
Most can be trained for any job. Only the basics in reading, writing and arithmetic are needed.
@Evie, HI Evie, I think an important question is whether the education system should be educating people in a general system of learning & knowledge, or training them to be workers…
There seems to be difference these days, but whether that is a function of the education system or “demand” from the employment sector… beyond me.
While interviewing and reading resumes for a job position in Kuwait which pays in excess of $100,000 tax free a particular resume comes to mind. One question asked the potential employee “what qualifies you for this position of power plant technician?” the response was “WILL WUKS EVER DAY!” I CRAP YOU NEGATIVE! and THIS from a supposedly college educated person….into the round file with much laughter, we never did fill the positions and there were four openings
I enjoyed your article. I never learned to think in school, but I’m now great at memorization and regurgitation. I learned so much more outside of school by reading the non-required texts. Something has to change in the system. We so far behind many other countries, and the youth today are not well educated, I think the system has gotten worse since I was a kid. I’m a Boy Scout leader, so I’m running into the boys in their middle school and high school years. Assuming my boys are a good example, it’s going to be disastrous. They can get a merit badge in a classroom setting, but when we are in the wilderness, they require a lot of hand holding. My child, who is in the womb, is being home schooled, and I’m doing my best to make sure we will be available to do it.
No one can really agree on what kind of education is needed, what kind of skills are valuable or how science and math fit into the equation.
When the economy is bad the emphasis is on education. When the economy is good the emphasis is in a production of human duds who will purchase as much as possibl
e.
The emphasis now is getting people to do as much work for as lityle pay as possible. This is true if you are a minimum wage employee at mickey ds or a medical dr.. The central planners want the benefit of your effort.
Supposed education leaves out all the great things about “Education”. I recently finished a college degree in pharmacy, and believe me when I tell you that the teacher/professor was as non-learned as the students! Few of my classmates/teachers could
1-Reason
2-Think or Create
3-Justify or explain a point of view
4-Form conclusions or judgements by facts or premise. Always fell back to the “it isn’t fair” argument.
5- Change an opinion by clear, logical dissent. It usually ended up a screaming match over ethnicity, religion, or being one of the “haves”.
6-Hard facts were irrelevant-emotion was everything.
I felt blessed to escape. I think that homeschooling is the way to go!
I think common sense is a HUGE part of teaching and learning. We are teaching our kids all about survival, gardening, hunting, raising animals, etc etc. We go camping all the time, do weed eating classes, fishing, etc. And we spend alot of time with our kids teaching them manners and respect. They go to a public school, but husband and I fill in alot of gaps school doesn’t teach them; just like money management.
We can blame ALL matters of education, but IMHO, 99.9% comes from the parents! Just like everything else, I decided to become a parent and don’t expect anyone else to raise my kids besides my husband and I- it’s our responsibility.
To ponder:
http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m5o43ptcPp1qbnxd3o1_1280.jpg